Pdf abstract consociational democracy as the goal and a tool in mitigating consociational democracy, arend lijphart, grand coalition, mutual veto, pro. Mar 14, 2015 of lijpharts two models of democracy, i believe that the consensus model is the most effective and most democratic system to implement. Pdf do characteristics of consociational democracies still apply. Almonds famous typology of political systems, first expounded in 1956, he distinguishes three types of western democratic systems. Consociational democracy can be found in countries that are deeply divided into in particular by arend lijphart, and is used today as both an analytical and a. Consociational democracy is based on proportional representation and as a type of democracy it is contrasted with centripetal democracy, which is based upon majority rule. Consociational democracy refers to systems where governments practice powersharing in deeply divided societies, typically along ethnic. Combining the expectations of endogeneity and the inclusiveness of. Most of what is written here does not refer to a consociational state, but to a consensus democracy. Evaluation of lijpharts model of consensus democracy the. By expanding lijpharts concept of majoritarian and consensus democracy for the most recent period 19972006, this paper examines the relationship between direct democracy and lijpharts institutional variables in 23 modern democracies. The main purpose of this work is therefore to examine the possibilities of using consociational democracy as a tool for conflict resolution in turkey, through arendt lijphart.
Consociational parties and political accommodation in. Lijphart then goes on to define proportionality as being a general principle of consociational democracy that applies not only to the electoral system but also to the composition of the public service and to the allocation of public funds 2000. Angloamerican political systems exemplified by britain and the united states, continental european political systems france, germany, and italy, and a third category consisting of. Here, once again, arend lijphart is directing our attention to matters which will surely engage much of the attention of students of comparative politics in the next. The consolidation of the consociational democracy in lebanon. Consociational theory suggests that powersharing institutions have many. While his power sharing model has been widely criticized, it is also being adopted in countries as diverse as the netherlands, india, austria, south africa, and malaysia. Pdf world politics volume 50, number 1, october 1997 find, read and cite all the research you need on. Almond merely states that the countries belonging to this type combine some of the features. Consociationalism an overview sciencedirect topics. Consociational democracy world politics cambridge core. In the late 1960s, arend lijphart proposed ethnicbased.
Consociational democracy in deeply divided society. Thinking about democracy assembles the cream of his essays on power sharing and comparative political analysis of the last forty years, and crowns them with fresh appraisals and commentary. Lijpharts frequent reformulations of consociationalist theory. Project muse lijphart, lakatos, and consociationalism. Recent advances in consociational theory luther and deschouwer, 1999 have elaborated on the crucial role of segmental parties in consociational democracy. The term was further elaborated into a general classificatory concept by arend lijphart. Illustration manual by the national commission on the parliamentary electoral. The article applies arend lijphart s theory of consociational democracy, or elite accommodation, and robert putnams theory of the twolevel game to european integration, using these theories. Power sharing and selfgovernance in consociational theory in the middle of the 19th century, the liberal philosopher john stuart mill in his considerations on representative government expressed skepticism with regard to the possibility of democracy zin. Consociational interpretations of the european union. Consociational democracy can be found in countries that are deeply divided into distinct religious, ethnic, racial, or regional segmentsconditions. Consociational democracy, class conflict, and the new.
Consociational democracy is a wellestablished method of conflict resolution, suggesting a powershared system among different segments in a plural society. Through the analysis of political systems in six continents, he demonstrates that what he calls consociational democracy can be successful in severely divided or plural societies. Arend lijphart page absoliutnogo i otnositelnogo bolshinstva versus proporsionalnoe predstavitelstvo, oikoumene kharkov, ukraine, vol. Patterns of democracy government forms and performance in thirtysix countries second edition arend lijphart. Comparative politics and the comparative method arend. Consociational democracy volume 21 issue 2 arend lijphart. Eight characteristics of nonmajoritarian democracyor consensus democracycan be identified. Since its rst formulation in the late 1960s lijphart, 1968, the concept of consociational democracy has been a moving target. What are the possibilities for consociational democracy to work as a tool for conflict resolution in turkey. According to lijphart, emerging democracies require increased efforts to. Abstract consociational democracy as the goal and a tool in mitigating conflict in the third world has been frequently used during the last decades, especially in subsaharan africa.
This dissertation looks at democracy in lebanon, a country that has a pluralistic society with many societal cleavages. The consolidation of the consociational democracy in. In light ofscholarly support for a consociational government i,n iraq, this. Nov 26, 2007 larry diamond, senior fellow, hoover institution, coeditor, journal of democracy arend lijphart s work has always been intellectually first class. According to the constitution, one or more governorates are allowed to merge and. Arend lijphart has made a great contribution to our understanding of nonmajoritarian democracy i. The limitations of the consociational arrangements in iraq. Consociational democracy as a tool for conflict resolution in. Corporate consociationalism predetermines power positions among ethnic and sectarian national groups, such as pre. View consociational democracy research papers on academia. Consociationalism, a stable democratic system in deeply divided societies that is based on power sharing between elites from different social groups.
Here, the extent to which the eu can be characterized as consociational ought to be analysed by four yardsticks. Abstract consociational democracy or konkordanzdemokratie has been described as the response of political elites in certain countries to the challenge of strong subcultural segmentation chapter 1, above. Lijphart famously distinguished four basic components of consociational democracy. The views expressed in this book are those of the author alone. However, in various countries, such as lebanon and iraq, consociational democracy has yielded corporate forms of power sharing that have been referred to as. Pdf consociational democracy in theory and practice.
But there should also be a clear article about consensus democracy. The relative stability of belgium is often attributed to its steady process of federalization in a consociational fashion. In this section, i will give a concise summary of the evolution of consociational theory. The author is indebted to the institute of international studies, berkeley, for financial support. This article explains the collapse of lebanons system of governance by viewing lebanon as a case of consociational democracy that could not be maintained after the prerequisites and conditions. Examining thirtysix democracies during the period from 1945 to 2010, lijphart arrives at importantand unexpectedconclusions about what type of democracy works best. Conference paper institutionalization of party systems. Powersharing and majority rule in theory and practice, london. However, it is the first one that focuses explicitly on consensus institutions and surveys their applicability in different environments. Based on a factor analysis, our main finding is that there are not just two, but three dimensions of. Political scientists define a consociational state as one which has major internal divisions along ethnic, religious, or linguistic lines, with none of the divisions large enough to form a majority group, but which remains stable due to.
Arend lijphart s 1969 article on consociational democracy was a compelling critique of prevailing theories of democratic stability and the launching pad for one of the most widely regarded research programs in contemporary comparative politics. You can merge consociationalism with consociational state, thats fine by me. In his work democracy and plural societies, lijphart explores the conditions under which stable and democratic multiethnic states, such as switzerland, belgium, austria, and the netherlands, are possible and concludes that consociational democracies involve multiparty cabinets, a multiparty system, proportional representation, political. Integrative from pol s 6 at university of california, santa barbara. Reexamining federalism and consociationalism as constitutional and political arrangements for community conflicts in post ottoman lands directed by nicos peristianis yucel vural university of nicosia, cyprus eastern mediterranean university, turkey peristianis. Consociationalism is a form of democracy which seeks to regulate the sharing of power in a state that comprises diverse societies distinct ethnic, religious, political, national or linguistic groups, by allocating these groups collective rights. I extract the core definition of consociationalism from lijpharts writ. Review and critique of the literature on consociational democracy. Lijpharts four conditions are absent in the consociational arrangements in iraq. May 26, 2008 arend lijphart is best known for his theory of consociational or power sharing democracy, which enables the peaceful governance of deeply divided societies. His efforts remind us that nonmajoritarian democracy is at least as legitimate as the majoritarian model, and may perform even better in many ways. As a response to the inherent risk of disintegration, belgium. Political accommodation is achieved by cooperation among the elites of segmental parties that each represents a single segment of society. The subject of this study is the consolidation of democracy in lebanon, described by arend lijphart as a consociational democracy.
1075 836 1351 982 1112 1343 1097 516 549 569 154 597 278 712 363 1375 1005 1293 1092 354 1598 1052 840 802 888 580 110 1039 1194 689 639 350